This debut novel by Alex Parvesi, a mathematician as well as
writer, takes the structure of the typical murder-mystery genre as its subject
and turns this into a series of clues that are meant to solve a crime.
Basically, the story is about an editor at a press dedicated to
publishing books in the crime genre, chasing down a famous author who lives on
a remote Greek isle with the aim of both
seeking his permission to publish a series of short stories he wrote over 20
years ago that prove his thesis about the structure of almost envy
murder-mystery (as he prefers to call them) ever written, as well as write an
erudite introduction explaining his theories. The original book was called The White Murders.
This is the frame narrative for what then becomes a series of
alternating chapters where the reader is given the seven short stories the
author wrote all those years ago (and which comprise the original book),
interspersed with conversations between him and his new publisher. Yet, in each
story, there are a series of irregularities, which when the publisher points
these out, the author either dismisses or explains away abruptly. When the
publisher questions him re the title, which also conjures up an actual brutal
murder of a young woman named White that occurred in England decades ago, and
the writer dismisses any relationship as mere coincidence, she begins to
question his response, not just to this, but to all her queries…
I enjoyed this slow burn of a novel. Drawing on the tropes of the
murder/mystery/crime genre, it explores it in a variety of homages – the
gumshoe PI, the femme fatale, the bully cop, the dogged investigator and
obvious and not so obvious suspects and victims. It bears echoes of Agatha
Christie, Sophie Hannah, Anthony Horowitz’s recent works and other writers of
British noir and crime. While the individual stories were in themselves quite
good, the conversation chapters between were often a bit lacklustre. The book
grows a bit repetitive and I was beginning to wonder where it was heading…
then comes the ending. The twists towards the end not only bring the book
together, but result in a very satisfying conclusion to a work that didn’t, for
a while, appear to be going anywhere meaningful.
Whereas for a while I thought I might not enjoy this book as much
as I hoped, the ending made the journey, which was clever and demonstrates a
real appreciation of the genre, very worthwhile.
Tags: crime, Eight Detectives by Alex Parvesi, murder mystery
Comments: No Comments
Veil of Lies is a
medieval “whodunnit” that pits the wits of a disgraced knight against the
equivalent of “the mob” as well as an elusive killer.
The disgraced knight
is one Crispin Guest, formerly of the House of Lancaster, but now of the less
than salubrious streets of London. Known as “The Tracker”, against his better
judgement, accepts a commission from a wealthy merchant who believes his wife
is being unfaithful. Required to follow the man’s wife, what Crispin discovers
confirms his employer’s concerns. When the merchant is found dead shortly after,
suspicion falls on the lovely wife. But Crispin is not convinced by her guilt.
When Crispin learns
that the merchant was also in possession of a valuable holy relic, a veil
believed to bear the impression of Christ’s face and which forces anyone in its
vicinity to speak the truth, he understands there are darker forces at work.
This is relic is something that other parties are willing to kill to possess. Suddenly,
a great deal more than a wife’s honour and a man’s life is at stake.
There’s no doubt Westerson brings the seamier side and brutality of this era London to vivid life in this tale of secrets, murder, and deception. The plot ticks along at a steady pace and with enough twists and turns to keep the reader guessing. As a hero, Crispin is somewhat wanting (which I also liked) as he struggles with his loss of status and the people he’s not only forced to reckon with daily, but how he’s perceived and treated by others as well. Crispin is an unapologetic snob who manages to seriously offend and thus offside those whose help and trust he needs, let alone those he likes. In that respect, the novel exposes the class system extant at the time and how much appearances and connections counted. The woman at the centre of the tale is also flawed, but I enjoyed reading a book that didn’t rely solely on binary characteristics to spin a good yarn – so much so, I’ve downloaded the next book in the Crispin Guest series.
Tags: marriage, murder mystery, Veil of Lies by Jeri Westerson
Comments: No Comments
This is the second book I have read recently with “seven” in the title, the other being the Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo which I enjoyed very much. Turton’s book, which was originally entitled The Seven and a Half Deaths etc (now that’s an eye-grabber) is a very different proposition. Essentially a murder mystery, it is also so much more. It’s also an existential exploration of what it means to be human – different kinds – and the ways in which we suffer for our sins, seek redemption, and/or must face the consequences of our actions. The setting is a decaying manor house, Blackheath, in the English countryside. The period appears to be the 1920s or something akin to that. A a group of guests have gathered to celebrate or be part of a memorial of a gruesome death that occurred many years earlier, and which has affected the Hardcastle family ever since. When one of the guests, a man we think is called Aiden (reading the book will explain why we only “think”), learns that the hosts’ daughter, Evelyn, is to be murdered that night and he has to uncover the identity of the culprit or else remain trapped in the manor house, reliving the same day over forever, you wonder what on earth is going on.
As each new day dawns, Aiden is thrust into a different body, viewing the world and the other guests from that perspective – a servant, a privileged gentleman, an artist, a con man, a doctor etc etc. Awareness of his previous day’s existence should work to help him solve the crime that doesn’t appear to be one, but it is just making things more convoluted and difficult to resolve. Add to that a brutal mystery man determined to murder anyone who comes close to solving the murder and a guy wondering around with a plague mask on whispering instructions and the entire house party takes on a surreal and sinister mood. Forming alliances and making enemies, Aiden is thrust into a body he thought he’d finished with, only to relive sections of the previous days, making matters worse. But time is ticking and Aiden will do anything to escape this hell…
While I really appreciate the idea behind this plot and the writing (which was really lovely in parts and excellent throughout), I also reached a point I too would do anything to escape this hell. I found the story hard to get into and, when I did, I didn’t care enough about the characters as I would have liked. They were all shallow, unpleasant, oft-times confusing and the purpose behind this never-ending Groundhog style day, but from alternate perspectives, became exasperating.
It wasn’t until near the end that the concept behind Blackheath and what it represents is revealed. Like the rest of the book, it’s clever (though some might not think so), but I was more relieved to be finished than gratified. That said, many have raved about this book, which is sort of an Agatha Christie on steroids. I did enjoy it very much at times, and can really appreciate the plotting and effort involved, but I think Evelyn could have died a fewer deaths
Tags: Agatha Christie, crime, existentialism, hose party, murder mystery, punishment, regret, revenge, The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton
Comments: No Comments
Having adored the BBC TV series, Poirot, starring David Suchet and having committed the literary cardinal sin of never reading one of Agatha Christie’s books featuring the Belgian detective (though I have read others), I thought I should give Sophie Hannah’s wonderfully titled novel, with the simply gorgeous art deco cover a whirl.
I am glad I did.
In this book, Poirot has, for some inexplicable reason, moved out of his accommodation and is living in a boarding house across the street where, conveniently, a young Scotland Yard detective, Edward Catchpool, is also staying. Acting on the recommendation of Catchpool, Poirot frequents the Pleasant Coffee House to take his meals. The book opens when Poirot is dining and a young, firghtened woman enters the coffee house and states that only when she is dead, will justice have been done before she exits, stage left.
When Catchpool is called upon to investigate the mysterious death of three motel guests, who all died at the same time in their rooms, Poirot senses that the young woman’s fears and this case are linked and thus the scene is set for Poirot to not only use his “little grey cells’ to prove they are, but educate Catchpool in the finer points of investigation. Journeying from London to a small village in the British countryside, Poirot and Catchpool find the answers to their present mystery lie in the past. But it’s up to Poirot to help the inexperienced Catchpool build those temporal bridges and join the literally bloody dots.
While I am not familiar with the style in which Agatha Christie wrote her Poirot books, there’s no doubt that when reading Hannah’s homage, it was easy to conjure a picture of Suchet as Poirot, fussing over his moustache, being particular about his things and places, so accurate was the dialogue and the descriptions of the vertically challenged, portly detective’s idiosyncrasies and ways of interacting with suspects. The language evoked a time and place very well as it did a range of eccentric British characters.
The climactic scenes with the revelation of just “who dunnit” did drag slightly, but other than that, this was an easy, delightful read that evoked the past in a charming, porcelain tea-cup way that made reading the book an easy pleasure.
Tags: Agatha Christie, murder mystery, Poirot, Sophie Hannah, The MOnogram Murders
Comments: No Comments
In an earlier review of Robotham’s works, I said they should come with a health warning as they render the reader unable to sleep. I want to correct that statement and instead recommend they be issued as a cure for narcolepsy, because I defy anyone to try and sleep while reading his latest work, Life or Death, because I sure as hell could not.
While I will read anything this man writes, I initially thought this was to be another in his Joseph O’Loughlin series and kept waiting for one of my favourite fictive characters (and his cop buddy, Vincent Ruiz) to make an entry. They don’t. This novel isn’t part of the O’Loughlin series and I initially experienced a small flash of disappointment that was swiftly staunched. That’s because this novel is a tremendous standalone with a fabulous premise: why would a man escape from prison the day before he’s due to be released?
That question is enough to arouse anyone’s curiousity, and I wondered how Robotham was going to pull off the story of Audie Palmer, a young man convicted of armed robbery ten years earlier and in which four people died, who flees his jail cell the day before he’s given state-sanctioned freedom for serving time. Reviled outside the prison, hounded endlessly within, Palmer’s life has been one of misery and hardship – so why does he make it worse by escaping? Why risk adding 20-25 years to his sentence by becoming a felon once more?
Palmer’s escape sets in motion a series of events over which he appears to have no control. Hunted by the authorities and criminals alike, Palmer is on a mission, but will he succeed and what’s the nature of this mission? Why didn’t he just wait one more day and walk from behind bars a free man?
This was a simply sensational tale. Taut, fast-paced, filled with believable characters, Robotham’s cracking dialogue, and original descriptions, I couldn’t put this down. Not only do the people come to life as the present and past unfold, but the different settings, the American landscape from the borders with Mexico to Texas, also develop a life of their own. You can smell the heat, taste the brackish water or the greasy eggs in an out-of-the-way diner, feel the sand, hear the flyscreens squeaking on rusty hinges as forlorn and deadbeat extras make an appearance. Despite having a horrible headache that required codeine, I stayed up till 3am to finish the book. I had to know what happened to Audie (who you come to champion so hard it hurts!), I had to know why he did what he did. The plot doesn’t only thicken in this novel, as back-stories and flashbacks weave their way in, laying solid foundations upon which the present is built, it sets harder than concrete making the conclusion one, though you don’t see it coming until the end, marvellously strong and utterly satisfying.
The only downside is that I have finished the damn thing and now have a long wait for Robotham’s next book. But if you like crime novels, edge of your seat thrillers, character driven works that also pay homage to setting, and are just superbly written, then I cannot recommend this highly enough.
Tags: Audie Palmer, crime, Joseph O'Loughlin, Life or Death, Michael Robotham, murder mystery, prison, Texas, thriller, Vincent Ruiz